What to Write Down: Keeping Strokes Gained by Hand

Strokes gained asks less of you than you think. For every shot it needs two facts: what the ball was lying on, and how far it was from the hole. Everything else is arithmetic.

That is little enough to keep with a pencil.

Why two facts are enough

The method comes from Mark Broadie of Columbia Business School, who set it out in Every Shot Counts. It values a shot by comparing where it started with where it finished.

From any spot on a course there is a benchmark: the average number of strokes a golfer of a given standard takes to hole out from that lie and that distance. A shot's strokes gained is the benchmark where it started, minus the benchmark where it finished, minus the one stroke you spent.

Take the simplest case. If the benchmark from your spot is 2.0 and you hole out in two, you gained nothing. Hole out in one and you gained a stroke. Take three and you lost one.

Here is what makes a hand record possible. Every shot finishes where the next one starts, so you never have to write down a finish. The next line is the finish. The last shot finishes in the hole.

The line

One line per shot: the shot number, the lie, and the distance to the hole before you hit it.

For the lie, a letter will do. T for the tee, F for fairway, R for rough, B for a bunker, G for the green. Add your own for the fringe and for the deep stuff. Write distances in yards until you are on the green, then in feet.

A par 4, written as you walk:

No. 7, par 4
1   T   410
2   R   165
3   B    20
4   G    12 ft
5   G     2 ft

Five lines, five strokes. Read it back and the hole is all there. The drive found the rough 165 yards out. The approach missed into a bunker 20 yards from the hole. The bunker shot finished 12 feet away, and it took two putts from there.

A scorecard would have said 5.

If a shot costs a penalty, put a P on its line. The stroke count still has to add up to your score, so the penalty stroke gets a line of its own.

Getting distances without a phone

You need less equipment than the method suggests.

  • From the tee, the card has the number.
  • For approaches, use the course's yardage markers and pace off the difference. A yardage book earns its place here.
  • Around the green, pace it. Most golfers can train a stride to a yard.
  • On the green, pace the putt and count each stride as three feet.

Be most careful where it matters most. The benchmark barely moves between 160 yards and 165. It moves a great deal between three feet and six. A sloppy number from the fairway costs you little, and a sloppy number on the green costs you the truth about your putting.

What the page shows before any arithmetic

A round written this way tells you things before you calculate anything. Count how often the second line of a par 4 starts with an R. Look at how long your first putts are. Look at what follows every B.

A scorecard hides those patterns, and they are usually where the strokes are going.

Turning the lines into numbers

The arithmetic needs a benchmark table, and that is the tedious part to do by hand. It is the part the Sand Iron app does. The app asks for the same facts, shot by shot: where each shot finished and how far that left you. Your lines are that list, in order. It then scores each shot against golfers of your handicap, not against tour players, and adds the round up off the tee, on approach, around the green and putting.

The app is not released yet. Neither is the printed yardage book Sand Iron members will get for keeping this record. Until both are ready, a pocket notebook and a pencil will hold a round, and the lines will keep.

A scorecard records what you made. This records how.